specs/015-gerrit-style-patchsets/review.md

Ref: main   Size: 1.3 KiB

# Pre-Implementation Review

**Feature**: Patch Revisions
**Artifacts reviewed**: spec.md, plan.md, tasks.md, checklists/revision-model.md
**Review model**: Claude Opus 4.6
**Date**: 2026-03-21

## Summary

| Dimension | Verdict | Issues |
|-----------|---------|--------|
| Spec-Plan Alignment | PASS | All user stories and FRs addressed |
| Plan-Tasks Completeness | PASS | Dispatch wiring now per-phase (fixed) |
| Dependency Ordering | PASS | Phases correctly ordered |
| Parallelization Correctness | PASS | [P] markers accurate |
| Feasibility & Risk | PASS | Simplified by removing backward compat |
| Standards Compliance | PASS | No constitution configured |
| Implementation Readiness | PASS | All tasks have exact file paths |

**Overall**: READY

## Findings

No critical or warning items remain after simplification (backward compat removed, dispatch wiring moved per-phase).

## Post-Review Changes Applied

1. Removed backward compat requirements (FR-011, FR-013, SC-005)
2. Made `commit`/`tree` on PatchCreate and `revision` on inline comments/reviews required (not Optional)
3. Removed `PatchRevise` event type entirely
4. Split dispatch wiring into per-phase tasks (T010a, T015a, T019, T022)
5. Added sync round-trip test case to T029
6. Clarified auto-detect runs for thread comments too (T005)